Gordon Ramsay really feels comfortable in critiquing others, as is shown in Hell’s Kitchen. But is criticizing the food at Buckingham Palace going a bit far?
Gordon Ramsay really feels comfortable in critiquing others, as is shown in Hell’s Kitchen. But is criticizing the food at Buckingham Palace going a bit far?
The Nerd Family gathered around the tv last night to watched the new Food Network show Food Detectives. The kids loved it, NerdDad and I though? Blah! Normally I love Ted Allen on Iron Chef America but what did they do to him for this show? He seems weird and oddly scripted. The facts, well while they are true they definitely are not all that shocking or sophisticated. Anyone who has watched Good Eats, Mr. Wizard or Myth Busters knew just about everything in that show. Also the “tests” were not complete nor logical in the data collected or in the analysis. I hope it gets better but this may be a show for my kids while I am doing other things. Then again my 7 year old knew about the Scoville scale so maybe this isn’t the fun science resource I and other homeschoolers were looking forward too.
Well, I am somewhat sad to say that Aaron McCargo Jr. won the Next Food Network Star this season.
All 3 contestants did 4 minute shows and I loved both Adam and Lisa’s. Aaron is the person I will probably watch the least. 2nd year in a row that I haven’t agreed with them. I didn’t really care for the Gourmet Next Door last year and I feel a bit vindicated that her show didn’t take off. Not that I am happy that the show did poorly just a bit vindicated in my judgment. It is obvious to me that the channel is looking for a new audience share. I hope it works out for Aaron and Food Network.
Separately, I tivo’ed Food Detectives and I have high hopes!
So I wanted to get some admissions and predictions out before tonight’s finale of The Next Food Network Star. I have been slowly becoming a Lisa Garza fan. The icy exterior has seemed to melt a lot and I am happy that her base of knowledge goes beyond the fruffy. Now the question remains, will she win? Well that I am not sure of but I think she should.
The question for the judge in this situation is what audience are you looking for? Adam is entertaining (usually) but he has very limited food knowledge. I personally am only so interested in smoking meat. He has other food knowledge but I don’t think he is confident enough to be able to put a show together with it. Aaron’s presentation is so hit and miss that I am not sure what food knowledge he does have. He also seems to not make real flavorful food (according to everyone who seemed to taste it). It wouldn’t take to many people trying some not so good recipes without Aaron losing all credibility. But both of the guys are a little more marketable to those who don’t really cook yet. I am a faithful network watcher and I would be most likely to watch a show with Lisa. I am already a bit of a foodie but being home taught I always need hints and tips.
So I am not sure who will win but I hope it is Lisa!
So here we are at this season’s finale. Christina gets handicapped by having Matt on her team and Petrozza was handicapped by Jen. I think Petrozza shot himself in the foot a little because it was so hard for his team to execute perfectly.
I think it was fitting for Christina to win. I was in a discussion today with someone who didn’t think she had paid the dues in years needed for this. I totally don’t agree. I believe in meritocracy. If she has proven that she has the knowledge and can put it into practice, why shouldn’t she get the job? We talked about if she was authoritative enough. Well, I think she is but the fact she can fire people helps with that. Not that she needs to rule a kitchen in fear but for those who won’t respect her just based on her age, that is how you deal with them.
The other thing for her kitchen to remember is, if you do a good job there is plenty of room in Gordon Ramsay’s restaurants for promotion.
So here is a simple 3 minute recap of the last episode of Next Food Network Star. I have to say that Lisa is definitely becoming more likable (and not just because of the comments I have been receiving;). I think that Kelsey is doing well but Tushman is against her because of her age and lack of authority. I think part of her authority issue is that she is short and the pinafore dresses. While those are cute dresses, they aren’t very mature.
I was a little blown away that Shane is out. I have a feeling that he will be picked up by someone, sometime and will be on tv again.
On the whole I think the judges were a bit tough this week. They slammed people from being to pushy with Rachel Ray or not dominating enough. It was very frustrating to watch.
Well, it is VBS week so I hope to post more later!
Technorati Tags: Food Network, Next Food Network Star
So here we are, down to the final 2 and the last step before the finale. Of course that means that we are at the “Set up your restuarant” challenge.
Christina goes back and starts working on her menu but Petrozza couldn’t focus and went to bed. At 36 hours until opening Christina has a menu and Petrozza doesn’t. Then they start meeting with the designer. The designer wants to see Petrozza’s menu to set the scene and he just throws out some ingredients. Christina seems to have strong opinions. Petrozza likes a celedon green chef’s jacket and flowers. Whereas Christina wants plain black suits and t-shirts. Then they worked on their menus with the sous chefs.
Then Ramsay calls them into his office and says he isn’t sure that he has the right finalists. But then he said he knows he does. That was a mean joke;). He tells them that they are going to New York City. They all pile into the private jet and go. They all get out in the middle of Times Square and the big screen has their names on it. He then tells them that he is going to send them both to Dubai for 5 days to eat at his restuarant and observe there. Christina doesn’t know where Dubai is. Then he took them to London New York and told them they had to cook their signature dish there.
They had 45 minutes to make their dishes. Petrozza is making a filet mignon with a risotto and demiglace. Christina was making an aged NY strip with succatash and fingerling potatoes. The judges were Ramsay’s 5 Executive Chefs. I have seen some of these chefs on a BBC America show. Petrozza won and as a reward he gets to choose first out of the contestants for his chefs. Then Whoopi came out. Can we just get to the cooking?!?!?!
Then they came back to LA. Petrozza is very happy with his dining room but Christina is not happy at all. Then they all go to sleep.
Next up is choosing their staffs.
Christina’s line up: Corey, LouRoss and ???
Petrozza’s line up: Bobby, Ben and ???
I think there wasn’t a lot of cooking in the episode and I find that dissapointing. This was very predictable if you have ever seen the previous seasons. But next week should be very good! See you then.
Technorati Tags: Hell’s Kitchen, Fox
This week we said goodbye to Jenn and I have to say that is wasn’t surprising at all. I really think that this is Kelsey or Shane’s to loose. They really seem to have it all but we shall have to wait and see!
See you next week for a more complete analysis.
Sorry for the delay in this week’s blog post but life has been nuts. So lets jump right in. Going in Christina is looking good but I don’t think that Ramsay likes her. I think he respects Petrozza but he is a mess in the kitchen. We shall see.
Ramsay is cooking for the final 3 and their families walk in. I remember the chefs having to do some cooking/challenge with the families so we will see why there are here. So after the families leave, the final 3 will have to recreate the dish they just ate. Christina seemed to be the only one on the ball enough to try to figure out what was in the dish.
Ramsay did provide them 1 sample dish for them to try again. Christina seemed to jump right in. Christina went with a white bean puree that she was really sure of. Corey used a parsnip puree and Petrozza didn’t use a puree at all. Christina’s mom was right on the cream as a binder but she didn’t use it. Corey used the wrong meat but finished the sauce right. Christina and Petrozza used the right meat (venison). In the end Christina won the challenge! That makes 3 in a row.
So Corey and Petrozza are on bar duty. That includes polishing classes and crushing block ice. I think that will really suck the energy out of them for service. Chrstina’s reward was a 3 course meal and sight seeing tour with Ramsay and her parents.
Of course we all remember that when we get to the final 3 they each get a chance to run the hot plate. Ramsay also gives each of them a little advice on how to do it.
Petrozza seemed to do pretty well. He caught the planted mistake along with some others. Christina seemed to be screwing up a lot while Petrozza was on the pass. Corey got on and seemed pretty aggressive and on it but she didn’t catch the sauce plant until it was to late. Christina took a second to get agressive but then she got the hang of being assertive. Christina caught the planted mistake (basil instead of mint).
Overall the service was completed well. After service Ramsay said he didn’t know who should go to the final. Corey was perfect on the meat station but not at the hot plate. Christina was good on the hot plate and not on the fish station. Petrozza was ok but not great. Then they each had to nominate one to go home. Corey nominated Christina because she becomes a deer in headlights when she get yelled at. Christina nominated Corey because she is a team member but not a leader. Petrozza nominated Christina because of the problems with service and that she will be a great chef but isn’t yet. In the end the final 2 are Petrozza and Christina.
See you next time for the final!
Technorati Tags: Hell’s Kitchen, Fox
So I found this great recap so you guys will only have to be exposed to my snark. So here are my impressions as they come to me!
First up is the technique video:
I think Adam did a real decent job with his artichoke cleaning. He goes with it and flows. Aaron was painful just blathering on about pineapple garnish. Kelsey did well but her rib wasn’t clean! Did Shane really try to pour out the coconut water with just 1 hole? This is why kids should pay attention in science class. 1 for things to come out and 1 for air to go in. If Nipa is trying to fake it she will have to quit giggling. Lisa doesn’t seem to realize that it is more important to communicate that to actually truss the chicken. I just wanted to cry with Jennifer.
Then the Challenge:
I think Kelsey may have locked it up by having Tilapia. Though I would have chosen the Fruit Loops instead of white chocolate. If Aaron doesn’t check the griddle temperature and then doesn’t compensate for over cooking before they even leave for the ship?? Maybe he isn’t the real deal. Did Adam really think falling on purpose would endear him to sailors? I am glad that Shane was finally able to get a decent presentation and his food to turn out. Lisa actually seemed very approachable but Tartar for Red Lobster? Eww! Nipa, grow a set and know that you will wash your hands later. It isn’t like raw fish will permeate you. I laughed at people like her in Bio class. Then the Ballywood dance lesson? I love it but you really have to consider your audience. I felt for Jennifer. I am an apologizer too. It just seems to have more integrity that way but I understand why that wouldn’t make for a good tv star.
Yes, I am harsh but maybe it is because it doesn’t seem that hard. Could I completely fillet a fish? No way, but getting a decent amount off? Sure!
I think the judges were totally right in sending Nipa home. Her time had come!
Technorati Tags: Food Network, Next Food Network Star